Trailing Stop vs Take Profit: The ATR Trail Lost Least on EURUSD, and a Fixed 1:3 Target Made $0.99 an Ounce on Gold
Key takeaways
- Trailing stop or fixed take profit? I ran both on identical entries: EMA 9/21 crosses on 16,926 EURUSD M5 bars and 13,736 gold M5 bars, plus Stochastic and random entries on EURUSD.
- On EURUSD the ATR trailing stop lost less than every fixed target on all three entry types. Best trail against best target: -1.22 vs -1.49 pips on EMA entries, -0.64 vs -0.95 on Stochastic, -0.71 vs -1.24 on random entries.
- On gold it flipped. A fixed stop of 1 ATR with a target of 3 ATR made $0.99 an ounce per trade after a $0.30 cost, profitable in both halves of the sample. All three trailing stops lost.
- On gold the fixed 1:3 was the only exit above its random-exit band. On EURUSD five of the six 1.5 and 2 ATR trail results were above theirs, and no fixed target was.
- So the answer depends on the market, not on which method is “better”. You can check which one your pair needs in about ten minutes.
Every trading course takes a side here. One camp says “let your profits run” and uses a trailing stop. The other says “plan the trade”, sets a fixed take profit at two or three times the stop and walks away. Both sound right, so I put them on the same entries and let the numbers decide.
The entries and the full list of 13 exit rules come from my exit signal test. Here I take only the two families everyone argues about.
What did I compare?
- Trailing stop: an ATR chandelier. The stop sits 1.5, 2 or 3 ATR 14 behind the best price since entry and moves only in the trade’s favour.
- Fixed take profit: stop and target set at entry in ATR: 1:1, 1:2, 1:3 and 2:2.
- Both: the same emergency stop at 3 ATR, one day maximum hold, one trade at a time. If one bar touched both stop and target, the stop counted.
- EURUSD: June 3 to August 26, 2026, 1-pip cost, median ATR 1.96 pips.
- Gold (GC=F): June 16 to August 26, 2026, $0.30 cost per ounce as in my gold vs EURUSD test, median ATR $4.62.
Which won on EURUSD?
| EURUSD M5, net pips per trade | EMA 9/21 entry | Stochastic entry | Random entry |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trailing 1.5 ATR | -1.22 | -0.76 | -0.85 |
| Trailing 2 ATR | -1.40 | -0.64 | -0.71 |
| Trailing 3 ATR | -1.92 | -0.96 | -0.91 |
| Fixed 1:1 | -1.53 | -1.13 | -1.37 |
| Fixed 1:2 | -1.63 | -1.00 | -1.30 |
| Fixed 1:3 | -1.49 | -0.95 | -1.24 |
| Fixed 2:2 | -1.96 | -1.20 | -1.51 |
736, 1,086 and 267 trades for the best trail in each column; 302 to 1,664 trades per fixed setting. Every cell is net of a 1-pip spread.
Nothing made money on EURUSD M5, which matches every rule I have tested on this pair at this timeframe. But inside that, the trailing stop won clearly. The tighter trails at 1.5 and 2 ATR beat all four fixed targets on all three entries. Five of those six tighter-trail results were also above the 95th percentile of random exits with the same holding times; only the 2 ATR trail on EMA entries was not. No fixed target managed that on EURUSD.
Which won on gold?
| Gold M5, EMA 9/21 entry | Trades | Win rate | Net $ per oz per trade | First half | Second half | Random exit, 5th to 95th pct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trailing 1.5 ATR | 497 | 35.6% | -0.80 | -1.97 | -0.05 | -0.85 to -0.05 |
| Trailing 2 ATR | 471 | 37.4% | -0.95 | -3.11 | +0.41 | -0.86 to +0.07 |
| Trailing 3 ATR | 350 | 36.6% | -0.12 | -1.49 | +0.73 | -0.69 to +0.78 |
| Fixed 1:1 | 498 | 52.6% | -0.25 | -0.70 | +0.03 | -0.85 to -0.22 |
| Fixed 1:2 | 455 | 36.7% | +0.37 | +0.81 | +0.12 | -0.54 to +0.49 |
| Fixed 1:3 | 423 | 30.0% | +0.99 | +1.27 | +0.83 | -0.56 to +0.64 |
| Fixed 2:2 | 332 | 53.9% | +0.74 | +0.51 | +0.87 | -0.53 to +1.07 |
Halves split at July 15, 2026. Net of $0.30 per trade.
On gold the trailing stops lost and three of four fixed targets made money. The fixed 1:3 was positive in both halves and above its random band. The 2:2 was positive in both halves too, but its random band reaches +1.07, so I would not call it proven.
Why does the same exit work on one market and not the other?
Look at how far trades went in their favour. On EURUSD, the EMA trades with the 1:3 target reached on average 2.54 pips of open profit at best, about 1.3 ATR, so most never got near a 3 ATR target. On gold the same exit saw $8.80 of open profit on average, about 1.9 ATR, and 30% of trades reached the target, each winner paying $15.53.
One way to read it: gold after an EMA cross often moves in one push and then snaps back. A fixed target takes the push before the snap. A trail 1.5 ATR behind the high gets shaken out by gold’s normal noise, then watches the move continue without it. EURUSD on M5 moves in smaller steps, rarely reaches a distant target, and there a trail that cuts dead trades early wins.
If you trade gold, the gold MT4 settings test lists which indicator settings held up on the same bars.
What about win rate?
| Average winner and loser, EMA entry | Win rate | Average win | Average loss |
|---|---|---|---|
| EURUSD, trailing 1.5 ATR | 24.7% | +4.52 pips | -3.10 pips |
| EURUSD, fixed 1:1 | 41.1% | +1.19 pips | -3.42 pips |
| Gold, trailing 1.5 ATR | 35.6% | +$6.69 | -$4.94 |
| Gold, fixed 1:3 | 30.0% | +$15.53 | -$5.25 |
The fixed 1:1 had the best win rate on both markets and paid on neither. The winner on each market had a win rate between 25% and 30%. Plan for long losing streaks with either method; my position sizing table shows what a run of ten losses does to an account at each risk level.
How do I choose for my own pair?
- Take your entry rule and record, for each trade, how far price went in your favour before it hit your stop. On the chart that is the highest high after a long entry, or the lowest low after a short one.
- Divide the average of those numbers by your ATR. If it is well under 2, a distant target will rarely fill: use a trail of 1.5 to 2 ATR. If it is near 2 or more, a fixed target at 2 to 3 ATR can work.
- Test both against a random exit with the same holding times, as in the exit signal test.
How to set a trailing stop in MT4 itself, and which pip values held up, is in my trailing stop settings guide. The stop-side version of this comparison is the fixed vs ATR stop test.
Frequently asked questions
Is a trailing stop better than a take profit?
On EURUSD M5 yes: an ATR trail of 1.5 to 2 lost less than every fixed target on all three entry types. On gold M5 no: the fixed 1:3 made $0.99 an ounce per trade and every trail lost.
What risk-reward ratio is best?
It depends on how far your trades usually run. On gold 1:3 was best. On EURUSD M5 no ratio paid after a 1-pip spread, and 1:3 was the least bad of the fixed ones.
How far should a trailing stop be?
1.5 to 2 ATR behind the best price did best on EURUSD. A 3 ATR trail gave back too much on both markets.
Why does a 1:1 take profit have a high win rate but lose money?
Because the spread comes out of every trade. On EURUSD the 1:1 average win was 1.19 pips after the spread and the average loss 3.42 pips.
Can I use both a trailing stop and a take profit?
Yes, but I did not test the mix here. Keep in mind that a target caps exactly the trades that pay for a trail, so test the combination against a random exit before using it.
Want a clean indicator to install right now?
It is my own enhanced DeMARK Trend Line indicator for MetaTrader 4 and 5. Non repaint, clean, and free.
Forex educator and indicator developer. I build and trade my own MetaTrader tools, and share the ones that genuinely help.